NEWS & RESEARCH
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which regulates trade in commodities and financial derivatives, has dramatically scaled back its enforcement under the Trump administration and is boosting, rather than policing, the growing cryptocurrency and prediction market industries.
In a recent action, the agency shut down the investigation of a commodities trading firm, Louis Dreyfus Company, at the direction of a Trump-appointed acting chairwoman, the New York Times has reported. CFTC lawyers had been readying civil charges against Louis Dreyfus, saying it misled markets about its cotton exports to China, thereby cheating American cotton farmers. The company was accused of deliberately hiding export deals, giving a false impression of actual demand, leading US growers to set their prices lower.
Since Trump took office, enforcement at the agency has fallen off dramatically. The regulator has filed an average of one new complaint a month for violations – about one fifth as many as under the Biden administration. Financial penalties imposed by the agency have plummeted as well, to fines worth $11 million so far in 2026, versus over $380 million at the same juncture two years ago.
The agency has also, since President Trump was elected, become a doormat for the fast-growing and lucrative cryptocurrency and prediction markets. Officials who raised questions about whether firms were treating small investors fairly, had sufficient protections against fraud, or had undergone adequate review before opening for business were put on leave and eventually pushed out. These industries have deep ties to the Trump family, and have generated enormous wealth for them – an estimated $1.4 billion in 2025.
Lax enforcement and oversight in the crypto and prediction markets increases the vulnerability to fraud and abuse of Americans who buy cryptocurrency or bet on predication markets. As these industries become interconnected with broader financial systems, risk becomes systemic.
SOURCES: New York Times | New York Times | The Dispatch | The Independent
ANALYSIS & OPINION
Since Trump took office, the CFTC, already a small agency, has cut its work force and pushed out career officials. With about 760 employees in 2015, it had about 550 workers in early 2026. Initially set up to watch for abuses in markets like farm goods, its portfolio has expanded to oversee a specialized but growing and highly lucrative sector of financial markets.
However, rather than policing against fraud and abuse, the agency’s political leadership has pursued steps to support and get out of the way of the businesses it is intended to oversee. The Trump administration’s first acting chairman of the commission, after sidelining regulatory actions, left to work for a cryptocurrency company. Prior to taking office, the current chairman, Michael S. Selig, represented crypto firms and worked as a lawyer with prediction markets. Political donors have used their influence to affect commission appointments and to expedite approvals.
Because President Trump has left the other seats vacant on what is meant to be a five-member, bipartisan commission, Selig is the lone commissioner, leaving him with unilateral authority to file lawsuits and issue new rules at a time when the industry is spending heavily and lobbying hard to shape business-friendly oversight.
Selig and the Trump administration argue they are reversing regulatory overreach and are focused on rooting out major abuses. However, the agency has announced far fewer cases against digital currencies than under the Biden administration. In addition, it appears to be using its enforcement authority selectively: the agency recently shut down an insider trading investigation linked to suspiciously timed bets on oil and stock prices just prior to a Trump announcement on Iran.
Not only does the CFTC’s about face from watchdog to lapdog put individuals and the broader market at risk, it directly benefits firms associated with Trump and his sons: 1789 Capital, Trump Media & Technology, and American Bitcoin.
Further, despite enthusiasm for digital assets among industry representatives and supporters, any discussion about regulation and oversight of cryptocurrency should squarely face concerns about the point of digital assets in the first place and their role in circumventing the law: "Crypto—after 18 years of effort and innumerable disproved and baseless claims—still lacks any real-world use case,” Benjamin Schiffrin, director of securities policy for Better Markets, wrote Oct. 5. “It is used either purely for speculation or for criminal purposes.” Trump, once a crypto skeptic, has undergone his own Road to Damascus conversion to believer – and beneficiary.
SOURCES: New York Times | New York Times | The Dispatch | Better Markets | | The New York Times
HOW TO FIX IT
Federal action:
Pass comprehensive guidelines for crypto that include reporting and compliance rules for digital assets.
The Guiding and Establishing National Innovation for U.S. Stablecoins Act (GENIUS Act, S. 1582) created a federal framework for stablecoins, a type of asset that is pegged to another asset, often a government-issued currency like the US dollar. It does not establish a general regulatory framework for all cryptocurrencies. Fidelity Investments noted: “… it would be wise to remember that cryptocurrencies are still highly volatile, and may still be more susceptible to market manipulation than securities. … [O]nly buy crypto with an amount you’re willing to lose.”
The Digital Asset Market Clarity Act (CLARITY Act, H.R. 3633), a broader crypto market-structure proposal would have clarified how federal oversight is divided between the Securities and Exchange Commission and CFTC and set rules for digital-asset markets and intermediaries. The measure failed in the Senate. Members opposing the measure said it fell short in the way it addressed ethics, consumer protection, and illicit finance. A Senate Banking Committee Democratic staff analysis concluded it would preserve Trump’s ability to profit from crypto ventures.
Prediction-market bill proposals range from barring certain sports or casino-like contracts to restricting officials’ trading on nonpublic information and banning particular event contracts.
Effective legislation on cryptocurrency must:
have adequate consumer protections
have broad ethics restrictions, including regarding whether officials can hold or trade digital assets as investments while carrying out policy responsibilities related to the digital asset industry maintain strong enforcement powers, including for state attorneys general and private parties
keep ethics provisions and enforceability in effect after the end of the current presidential term
sufficiently address money laundering and financial crime risks associated with the digital asset industry
not pre-empt state anti-fraud enforcement actions
strengthen provisions relating to market integrity and addresses any potential national security risks from unregulated digital asset markets.
Fill the four open positions on the CFTC board and rehire lawyers to truly enforce the laws.
Strengthen ethics and revolving-door rules. Require meaningful cooling-off periods and clear recusals for officials handling matters involving former or prospective employers.
Protect independent judgment. Give the CFTC stable funding and enough staff, economists, technologists, and enforcement capacity to analyze industry data and challenge industry-provided assumptions.
State action:
Clarify and rationalize the regulatory regimes: Oversight is fragmented. States regulate crypto businesses mainly through financial-services laws, while prediction markets—especially sports-related contracts—are being contested under state gambling laws. Crypto oversight usually means state-by-state financial licensing and supervision. Some states have dedicated digital-asset regimes. Prediction-market oversight is currently subject to state-versus-federal jurisdiction fights, with state gambling laws actively being applied or challenged depending on the product and jurisdiction.
Litigation:
As of October 2026, 44 state attorneys general have publicly attacked prediction market contracts as a "new form of casino," asserting that they evade state taxes—estimated at over $2 billion annually in lost revenue—and ignore state-mandated consumer protection laws. Multiple states have launched enforcement actions against prediction markets and crypto operators, including Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase, Gemini, and Crypto.com. The disputes include whether platforms can offer sports contracts without state gambling licenses. However, the CFTC and Justice Department are asserting exclusive federal regulatory authority and, as of June 2026, had sued Arizona, Connecticut, Illinois, New York, New Mexico, Minnesota, Rhode Island, Wisconsin, and Kentucky to block state gambling-law enforcement against federally registered prediction-market exchanges. The core legal question is whether sports and other event contracts traded on federally registered exchanges are derivatives under the Commodity Exchange Act—placing them under the CFTC’s exclusive authority—or gambling that states can regulate.